Redefining Boundaries: From Rules to Self-Guidance

Rules & Requests are NOT Boundaries…

Have you felt disrespected, frustrated, and angry when someone “crosses your boundary”? Well, good news, you are human, as we’ve likely all been in this space before. You might be searching for a better to communicate your boundary and ensure that it is upheld. I want to propose that is has nothing to do with being “better” and everything to do with doing things “differently”. First up – understanding a rule versus a boundary. A rule attempts to guide the behaviour of others – for example, “stop emailing me before 9 am, stop saying that kind of stuff around me, I need you to change this behaviour, etc etc etc”. No one wants to be told what to do, whether you are 3, 43, or 93. Rarely does placing a rule generate a desired outcome for anyone.


News flash – this isn’t a boundary; it’s a rule. Rules are about guiding and/or forcing the behaviours of others to be in line with ours. The intention of boundaries is more about guiding the behaviours of me, me, myself, and I. For example, “I want to let you know that I will not be responding to any messages before 9am” or“ If the comments about my body continue to happen at this table, I will not be returning for dinner,” or “I love that you want to hug my kids when we are leaving yet I want you to know what we don’t force hugs from our kids for anyone. You can ask them how’d they like to say goodbye and respect their choices”. You see, the only person that can violate a boundary is you. Boundaries are about guiding your behaviour based on what is okay and what is not FOR YOU. Sometimes that means having a conversation with another person or party and sometimes it means holding a conversation within. Take a scroll down and see how this could look:

Determine your intention/need/why behind the boundary (creating your foundation).

Assess whether it is safe (physically/mentally, emotionally, culturally, etc) to share with the other person or persons (ask yourself “are they in a position to sit in discomfort with me, do they have the emotional maturity to be invited in, can they hold my truth with curiosity and kindness?)

Depending on the assessment:

If the answer is yes – proceed with the conversation via face to face, phone, text, facetime, etc (this is an example of a loud boundary – you are sharing it with someone or a set of someone’s). Using a soft start up is key – focus on” I statements”, “I feel this when this happens because of this and going forward this is what I will be doing, changing, shifting, etc”

If the answer is no, you will lean into a quiet boundary – you are keeping a boundary to yourself (you create this for you and you share it with your inner self) about that person or group to either protect yourself, your progress, your energy, or to preserve what is left of the relationship.

Share the Post:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More from the Journal

  • All
  • Body Acceptance and Fat-Positivity
  • Boundaries
  • Couples Counselling and Marriage
  • Mental Health and Wellness
  • Mindfulness and Self-Care
  • Pregnancy, Postpartum, and Motherhood
  • Relationships and Communication
  • Self Help & Personal Development
  • Trauma and Healing
A person holding a stack of colorful self-help books, partially concealing a t-shirt with a graphic design.

Understanding Boundaries: A Guide from the Boundary Therapist living and learning in Saskatoon

The Essence of Personal Boundaries Personal boundaries are the limits we set to protect our physical, emotional, and mental health. They define what is acceptable ...
Mindfulness and Self-Care

The Role of Physiotherapy in Whole Person Care in Saskatoon

How can we sift through the noise? There are a lot of health and wellness buzzwords out there and it can be hard to discern ...
Couples Counselling and Marriage

Communication is Sexy: Igniting Passion Through Emotional Connection this Valentine’s Day

Love is in the air, and what better time to celebrate the essence of deep emotional connection than Valentine’s Day? In the realm of relationships, ...

Stay Updated with Breland Journal

Join our email list to receive the latest articles, insights, and updates from Breland Journal straight to your inbox. Don't miss out on valuable content tailored to support your journey towards wellness and personal growth.